Article Text

PDF

India: “low-risk” launch
  1. David Simpson
  1. d.simpson{at}iath.org

    Statistics from Altmetric.com

    In recent months, there has been mounting concern about two new and apparently related developments.

    First, a previously unknown non-governmental organisation (NGO) had appeared on the scene, predominantly web-based and calling itself simply www.LowTobaclife.com. Its website carried a range of soft lifestyle features, and in a health section, apparently credible advice about tobacco. However, this led on to “Doctor’s quotes on Low Tobacco Cigarette” [sic], which led readers into a discussion strongly reminiscent of the discredited industry line that what is really needed for smokers who cannot give up is a new, reduced toxicity product. There was no information about who was behind the new NGO, which was starting to receive widespread publicity. What was of most concern to health advocates was that its spokesperson was quoted alongside comments from established tobacco control organisations. In June, the NGO took its first newspaper advertisement, in the Mumbai edition of The Times of India, informing readers, “Tobacco is injurious. Go Low on Tobacco. High on Life”, and inviting them to visit its website.


    Embedded Image

    The newly launched LoeTabac brand, which claims to achieve “safer delivery levels” of tar, carbon monoxide and tobacco-specific nitrosamines.

    Next, and more serious, came the news that a new brand of cigarette had been launched, called LoeTabac, made by an Indian company, GTC Industries Limited (formerly known as Golden Tobacco Company Limited). The near-identical names of the new brand and the new NGO seemed too great to be a coincidence, and suspicions of a formal link were strongly reinforced by the appearance of the slogan “High on life” under the brand name on the pack. GTC was reported as claiming that LoeTabac had been found to have “safer delivery levels” of tar, carbon monoxide and tobacco-specific nitrosamines than other brands.

    This is clearly a worrying development, seemingly aimed at the millions of addicted smokers who desperately hope that by changing to a new brand like this, they may escape the majority of risks of continued smoking. Holding out the prospect of “safer” smoking was being perpetrated by the big tobacco companies in countries such as the UK and the USA more than a quarter of a century ago, and it seemed reasonable to hope that they would not be seen in the 21st century. Of course, it is just possible that the new brand could be significantly different, but it would take a long time for a properly designed trial to prove it. It is to be hoped that the Indian government steps in to investigate and, at the very least, regulate it properly.


    Embedded Image

    Canada: now you see it, now you don’t Intention or chance? The apportionment of the health warning text on this oral snuff container, and of the French language version on the other side, creates a serious flaw when the lid is removed.

    Meanwhile, even the tobacco trade journal Tobacco Reporter observed that the international marketing of the brand “will raise some interesting questions in some countries” and that the suggestion in the word “Loe” and the slogan “High on Life” slogan below the brand name “might well cause apoplexy among some health ministers”. And probably among some readers of Tobacco Control, too.


    Embedded Image

    USA: White House, black coffins Dr Javaid Khan of Pakistan holds a banner over coffins symbolising those dying from tobacco, including those who smoked cigarettes sold abroad by US tobacco companies. The demonstration was one of a series of newsworthy events carried out mainly by youth advocates from around the world who were attending the world conference on tobacco and health in Washington DC in July.

    View Abstract

    Request permissions

    If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.