Article Text

PDF

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Play It Again is a section of the journal where we republish quotes, gaffes, and immortal lines from friends and foes of tobacco control. It is compiled by Gene Borio, the webmaster of Tobacco BBS, which is the premier tobacco newsgathering site on the internet. Send contributions (including an original version or photocopy of the sourced item) to him at Tobacco BBS, PO Box 359, Village Station, New York 10014-0359; fax 001 212 260 6825. Send quotes from online stories (including the full article) or scanned documents (in GIF or JPEG format), togborio{at}mindspring.com

 “Smoking is a custom loathsome to the eye, hateful to the nose, harmful to the brain, dangerous to the lungs, and in the black, stinking fume thereof nearest resembling the horrible Stygian smoke of the pit that is bottomless.”

Source: James I of England, “A Counterblaste to Tobacco”.

 “Smoke! Smoke! Smoke! (That Cigarette)”

Source: Song written by Merle Travis for Tex Williams, a national hit in 1947. It includes the lyric “Puff, Puff, Puff, And if you smoke yourself to death”.

These quotes, along with terms like “cancer stick”, “poison sausage”, “little white slaver”, “smoker's cough”, and “nicotine fit”, are often used by tobacco apologists, witnesses and lawyers in an attempt to prove that everyone—well, except tobacco CEOs—has always known that tobacco was “bad for you” and addictive.

But it's not as if James or even Tex were scientists; nor were theirs the only voices being heard in society. And just because an idea is heard, it doesn't perforce mean that it is believed or given weight. This argument is a bit like saying people always knew extraterrestrial life was hidden behind comets (citing Marshall Applewhite), or that alligators prowled the sewers, or that the earth was flat.

In fact, you could just as well say that everyone has always known tobacco is good for you, since people have heard that a lot too.

So, let's travel back in time, and listen in on a few other things people “always knew”.

 divine herb

holy herb (herba sancta)

Soverane Herb

bewitching vegetable

These were some common historical terms for tobacco.

the Queen's herb (Herba Regina)

Catherine de Medici, Queen of France, was so happy with the tobacco Jean Nicot sent to her to relieve her migraines, she decreed it should be named “Herba Regina” (1561).

herba panacea

“De herba panacea seu medicina tabac” (Everartus, A Antwerp, 1587) is the first known book solely on tobacco.

“[Brazilian natives] esteeme it maruellous profitable for many things . . . They say it is very holesome to cleanse & consume the superfluous humors of the brain.”

Andre Thevet, “France antarctique” (Antwerp, 1558). Source: Dry drunk: the culture of tobacco in 17th- and 18th-century Europe, The New York Public Library, Exhibition: 20 September1997 - 3 January 1998.

“Griefs of the breast”

One of tobacco's many curatives, according to Mondardes. The 1571 publication of Monardes' second book on American herbs (which featured tobacco on its title page) had a broad popularising effect. “Griefs of the breast” included shortness of breath. Among the other problems tobacco was thought to remedy were: griefs of the head, breast, stomach, and joints; the “evil of the mother” (apparently labour pains); “evil breathing at the mouth of children” (halitosis); worms; toothache; and old, new, and venomous wounds, lockjaw, and cancer.

Nicolás Monardes (Spanish, ca. 1512–1588); John Frampton (British, active 1577–96), translator, “Ioyfull newes out of the newe founde worlde, part II” London: William Norton, 1577. * * *

“There is an herb called uppowoc, which sows itself. In the West Indies it has several names, according to the different places where it grows and is used, but the Spaniards generally call it tobacco. Its leaves are dried, made into powder, and then smoked by being sucked through clay pipes into the stomach and head. The fumes purge superfluous phlegm and gross humors from the body by opening all the pores and passages. Thus its use not only preserves the body, but if there are any obstructions it breaks them up. By this means the natives keep in excellent health, without many of the grievous diseases which often afflict us in England.

“This uppowoc is so highly valued by them that they think their gods are delighted with it. Sometimes they make holy fires and cast the powder into them as a sacrifice. If there is a storm on the waters, they throw it up into the air and into the water to pacify their gods. Also, when they set up a new weir for fish, they pour uppowoc into it. And if they escape from danger, they also throw the powder up into the air. This is always done with strange gestures and stamping, sometimes dancing, clapping of hands, holding hands up, and staring up into the heavens. During this performance they chatter strange words and utter meaningless noises.

“While we were there we used to suck in the smoke as they did, and now that we are back in England we still do so. We have found many rare and wonderful proofs of the uppowoc's virtues, which would themselves require a volume to relate. There is sufficient evidence in the fact that it is used by so many men and women of great calling, as well as by some learned physicians.”

Thomas Hariot, a brief and true report of the new found land of Virginia. Imprinted in London in 1588. Source: Lorant, S. The New World, “Duell, Sloan & Pearce,” New York 1946, page 246.

“Into the woods thenceforth in haste shee went,

To seeke for hearties that mote him remedy;

For she of hearties had great intendiment,

Taught of the Nymphe which from her infancy

Her nourced had in trew nobility:

There, whether yet divine Tobacco were,

Or Panachea, or Polygony,

She fownd, and brought it to her patient deare

Who al this while lay bleding out his hart-blood scare.”

Belphoebe includes tobacco with other medicinal herbs gathered to heal Timais (Book III, Canto VI, 32). This is the earliest poetical allusion to tobacco in English literature

Spenser, E. Fairy Queen, 1590.

“The first book in the English language devoted to the subject of tobacco was anonymously published in 1595, by Anthony Chute. It has the simple title “Tabacco” and contains an illustration of an Englishman smoking a clay pipe. In this little work for laymen, the author earnestly urged smokers not to abuse the kindly weed, upheld its medicinal uses, and suggested that physicians were trying to keep smoking a secret among themselves. The reason was, he said, that a moderate use of the pipe was of such value in preserving health that it was likely to make physicians unnecessary!”

Source: Arents, G. “Early Literature of Tobacco”; privately printed for distribution at The Library of Congress, 1938.

“The Vertues of Tobacco”

In 1614, William Barclay touted tobacco's medicinal qualities. Source: Barclay, W Nepenthes, or the Vertues of Tabacco, Edinburgh, 1614.

“This day, much against my Will, I did in Drury-lane see two or three houses marked with a red cross upon the doors, and ‘Lord have mercy upon us’ writ there—which was a sad sight to me, being the first of that kind that to my remembrance I ever saw. It put me into an ill conception of myself and my smell, so that I was forced to buy some roll-tobacco to smell and to chew, which took away the apprehension.”

In times of plague, smoking tobacco was thought to have a protective effect. During London's Great Plague (1665-66), smoking was made compulsory at Eton to ward off infection. The practice has been noted since at least 1614.

Diary entry for June 7, 1665. Source: Pepys, S. “The diary of Samuel Pepys” (1633-1703).

“Whatever Aristotle and the whole body of philosophers may say, there's nothing comparable to tobacco: ‘tis the reigning passion of your better sort of people, and he who lives without tobacco deserves not to live; it not only exhilarates and purges human brains; it also trains the mind to virtue, and by this one learns to become well bred. Don’t you see plainly, from the time one takes it, in what an obliging manner one uses it with all the world, and how one is delighted to give it right and left wherever one comes? One doesn't even wait to be asked for it, but anticipates people's wishes; so true it is that tobacco inspires all who take it with sentiments of honor and virtue.”

Source: Moliere, “Don Juan”, 1665.

“My Lady Nicotine”

James Barrie's ode to the delights of nicotine. Source: Sir James Barrie, “My Lady Nicotine”, London 1890.

“Rides like an Arab, Smokes like a Zouave . . .Enfant de L'armee, Femme de la Fume, Soldat de la France.”

Passages describing Cigarette, the waif heroine of Under Two Flags. Source: Ouida (Louise de la Ramee) “Under Two Flags”, 1894.

“It is an admitted fact that a disease of the vision—tobacco amblyopia—is contracted by smokers . . .Allowing that such incidental evils may arise from even comparatively moderate indulgence in tobacco, they are after all as nothing compared to the vast aggregate of gentle exhilaration, soothing, and social comfort, extracted from Virginia weed.”

Encyclopaedia Britannica, 10th edition, New American supplement, 1902, page 427. [There is no mention of tobacco amblyopia or health issues at all in the 1911 edition.] Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica, 10th edition, New American supplement, 1902, page 427.

“The removal of tobacco from the Pharmacopoeia was the price that had to be paid to get the support of tobacco state legislators for the Food and Drug Act of 1906. The elimination of the word tobacco automatically removed the leaf from FDA supervision.”

The definition of a drug, for FDA legislation, included medicines and preparations listed in US Pharmacoepia or National Formulary. The 1914 interpretation advised that tobacco be included only when used to cure, mitigate, or prevent disease. Source: Smoking and politics: policymaking and the Federal bureaucracy, Fritschler, A Lee. 1969, page 37.

“That the claims of those who inveigh against tobacco are wholly without foundation has been proved time and again by famous chemists, physicians, toxicologists, physiologists, and experts of every nation and clime.”

Atlantic Monthly, October 1920. Source: Kluger, R. Ashes to ashes, 1996, page 68.

“A dispassionate review of the [scientific] findings compels the conclusion that the cigarette is tobacco in its mildest form, and that tobacco, used moderately by people in normal health, does not appreciably impair either the mental efficiency or the physical condition.”

American Mercury, December, 1925. Source: Kluger, R. Ashes to ashes, 1996, page 68.

“‘Don’t smoke' is advice hard for patients to swallow. May we suggest instead ‘Smoking Philip Morris?’ Tests showed three out of every four cases of smokers' cough cleared on changing to Philip Morris. Why not observe the results for yourself?”

1943 Philip Morris ad in the National Medical Journal. Source: The State of New York v. Philip Morris, et al, 1997 January 27.

“Smoke, drink, and get well”

Article by Dr William D Stroud, professor of cardiology at the UPenn Graduate School of Medicine in Newsweek, 1946 . Source: Stroud, W. Smoke, drink and get well, “Newsweek” 2 December 1946.

“[M]ore can be said in behalf of smoking as a form of escape from tension than against it . . . [T]here does not seem to be any preponderance of evidence that would indicate the abolition of the use of tobacco as a substance contrary to the public health.”

The Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA), 1948. Source: Kluger, R. Ashes to ashes, 1996, page 132.

“A scientific perspective on the cigarette controversy”

April 14, 1954 TIRC booklet, which was mailed to over 200 000 people, including doctors, members of Congress and the news media. Source: State of Mississippi v The American Tobacco Company, et al. 1994.

“Timothy V. Hartnett, chairman of the Tobacco Industry Research Committee, called the poll of doctors ‘biased, unscientific and filled with shortcomings’.”

In 1954, newspaper articles started getting the TIRC's response appended. The above quote is from a June 7 front page article about an American Cancer Society meeting at which a poll found most cancer researchers, chest surgeons, and pathologists believed that smoking might lead to lung cancer. Source: White, L. Merchants of Death, William Morrow, 1988.

“Why stop smoking?

new, up-to-the minute revelations on the smoking scares! new help . . .new reassurance for smokers!”

Promotion for Albert Ostrow's “Why stop smoking?” Source: WHY STOP SMOKING, Lorillard, 1955 May 18. Bates #: TDO 558383. URL: http://my.tobaccodocuments.org/tdo/view.cfm?CitID=558383&GetListArrayIdx=1&ShowImages=yes (Smokescreen.org)

“Tobacco—the world's most popular plant”

1963 15 minute slide sound film released by the Tobacco Institute.

“Perhaps the last word should be left to the doughtiest unbeliever of all. In Western Germany, the secretary general of the International Association for Scientific Tobacco Research, Dr H Aschenbrenner, suggests that before reports on smoking and health are taken seriously, those making the reports should have psychiatric certification that they are not suffering from pyrophobia (fear of fire). Twenty-five years' research by his organization, says Dr Aschenbrenner, have proven that tobacco antagonism often springs from a morbid (and often unconscious) pyrophobia—a phenomenon whose many manifestations include suppressed fear of the ‘big fire’ or atom bomb.”

Source: International perspective on smoking and health, “World Tobacco”, 1964, page 20.

“To Smoke or not to smoke—that is still the question”

January 1968 True Magazine article by Stanley Frank, a widely read sportswriter.

“Cigarette cancer link is bunk”

A similar article in the National Enquirer, written by “Charles Golden”; the real author was Frank.

Two million reprints of the True Magazine article were distributed to physicians, scientists, journalists, government officials, and other opinion leaders with a small card which stated, “As a leader in your profession and community, you will be interested in reading this story from the January issue of True Magazine about one of today's controversial issues.” The cost for this was said by Brown and Williamson, Philip Morris and RJ Reynolds. It was subsequently disclosed that author Frank had been paid $500 by Joseph Field, a public relations professional working for Brown and Williamson, to write the article. Source: Whelan, E. A Smoking gun: how the tobacco industry gets away-with murder, George F Stickley Co, 1984.

“This book is for Rose Tinker Mallan, my lovely non-smoking wife, who worries with renewed emphasis every time she reads another scare headline in the newspapers “linking” cigarette smoking with disease.”

Dedication for “It issafe to smoke” by Lloyd Mallan, Hawthorn Books, 1968.

“After 15 years of trying, nobody has induced lung cancer in animals with cigarette smoke . . . We believe that the anti-cigarette theory is a bum rap.”

Full page ad placed in the New York Times by one of the tobacco companies in 1969. Source: Wagner, S. “Cigarette country: tobacco in American history and politics” Praeger Publishers 1971.

“The more cigarettes a person says he smokes, the more likely he is to be checked by his physician for lung cancer. Thus, cigarette smoking may be contributing more to the diagnosis of lung cancer than to the disease, said Dr Feinstein of Yale University.”

News report covering Dr Alvan R Freinstein's address at the annual meeting in the Association of American Physicians. Source: Smoking link to lung Ca Termed Diagnostic Bias, “Family Practice News”, 1974 July 15. Bates #: TITX 0002372 ( http://my.tobaccodocuments.org/tdo/view.cfm?CitID=127054 ) To see evidence of Dr Feinstein's involvement with the CTR's “Special projects”, see: Bates:201702/5370 (1965) ( http://www.pmdocs.com/getalling.asp?DOCID=2017025366/5370 ) and Bates: 507731452 (1988) ( http://my.tobaccodocuments.org/tdo/view.cfm?CitID=966722 ).

But all that is past now, isn't it? Bygones! After all, the Philip Morris site clearly states:

“There is an overwhelming medical and scientific consensus that cigarette smoking causes lung cancer, heart disease, emphysema and other serious diseases in smokers . . .There is no “safe” cigarette. These are and have been the messages of public health authorities worldwide. Smokers and potential smokers should rely on these messages in making all smoking-related decisions . . . Cigarette smoking is addictive, as that term is most commonly used today.

Source: Cigarette smoking: health issues for smokers. “Philip Morris” http://www.philipmorris.com . Accessed 1999 October 13.

Koppel: “If I say to you Steve Parrish, right now, tell me is nicotine addictive, you will have no trouble saying yes, is that correct?”

Mr Parrish: “I will have no trouble saying what exactly is on our Web site, that under the definition that's commonly used today, it absolutely is . . .”

Koppel: “All right, you were good nine years ago. You're even better today.”

Source: Nightline: Philip Morris admits smoking causes cancer. “ABC News” 1999 October 14.

Szymanczyk: “The company's position is that there is an overwhelming scientific and medical consensus that smoking causes lung cancer and emphysema and other diseases.”

Rosenblatt: “Has Philip Morris ever said on its Web site or anywhere else that we as a company agree with that consensus?”

Szymanczyk: “We have not.”

From the May 10 deposition of Michael Szymanczyk, president and CEO of Philip Morris Inc. Wilson, C. Tobacco chief denies targeting kids, “AP” 2000 May 20.

“[I] gave up smoking on the quack's advice a few months ago . . .It proved wrong.”

Philip Morris CEO Geoffrey Bible, to the Sydney Morning Herald, which points out Bible has not gone back to smoking. Hale, B. Big Mo's snack attack cuts tobacco drag, “Sydney Morning Herald” 2000 June 28.

Question: “Did plaintiff's smoking constitute a substantial factor in the cause of his lung cancer?”

Answer: “No.”

The first question on the Anderson trial's 21 page verdict form. The “No” answer obviated the rest. Geyelin, M. Tobacco industry wins lawsuit filed by smoker from Brooklyn, “The Wall Street Journal Interactive Edition” 2000 June 28.

“[It appeared] the jury accepted the defense contention that bathtub refinishing is more likely a cause of lung cancer than 30 years of smoking Salems.”

Mark Gottlieb, a staff attorney with the Tobacco Products Liability Project, on the Anderson verdict. Levin, M. Tobacco firms win round in NY court, “Los Angeles Times” 2000 June 28.

“Stunned docs discover cigarettes stop Parkinson's”

Source: Field, R. “New York Post” 1995 June 15.

“Is smoking good for you? There are health benefits.”

Source: “New York Post” 1994 July 11.

For years, these were the only two articles on smoking and health I could find in Rupert Murdoch's rabidly pro-Philip Morris New York Post. Had you been a reader of the Post throughout the PM board member Murdoch's stewardship, you might be forgiven for thinking that tobacco is, indeed, good for you!

View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.