Table 4 Comparison between responder and non-responder groups at 12 months, n = 1044
ParameterRespondersNon-respondersp Value
n = 685 (65.6%)n = 359 (34.4%)
Randomisation, n (%):
ETC group338 (49.3)177 (49.3)0.990
Control group347 (50.7)182 (50.7)
Age in years, median (range)30 (18–81)29 (18–78) <0.001
Gender, n (%):
Male396 (57.8)234 (65.2) 0.021
Female289 (42.2)125 (34.8)
No. of cigarettes smoked per day during the last 7 days (n = 1012), median (range)15 (1–60)15 (1–60)0.124
Nicotine dependency (n = 1012), n (%):*
Low310 (45.3)114 (34.9)
Medium158 (23.1)83 (25.4) 0.002†
High217 (31.7)‡130 (39.8)‡
Motivation to change smoking behaviour, n (%)§:
Unmotivated smokers375 (54.7)205 (57.1)
Ambivalent smokers227 (33.1)104 (29.0)0.905†
Motivated smokers83 (12.1)‡50 (13.9)
Attempts to quit smoking during the last 12 months (n = 1012), n (%):
None395 (57.7)189 (57.8)
1153 (22.3)79 (24.2)0.667†
2–5111 (16.2)48 (14.7)
>526 (3.8)11 (3.4)‡
Hazardous alcohol consumption (n = 1012), n (%):¶
Yes221 (32.3)128 (39.1) 0.031
No464 (67.7)199 (60.9)
Illicit drug use (last 12 months) (n = 1012), n (%):
None430 (62.8)184 (56.3)
1–3 times109 (15.9)49 (15.0) 0.006†
4 times up to weekly84 (12.3)47 (14.4)
Several times per week to daily62 (9.1)‡47 (14.4)‡
School education (n = 1012), n (%):
Discontinued5 (0.7)8 (2.4)
10 years311 (45.4)173 (52.9) <0.001
11–13 years364 (53.1)137 (41.9)
In school education5 (0.7)‡9 (2.8)
Family doctor (n = 1012), n (%):
Yes507 (74.0)217 (66.4) 0.012
No178 (26.0)110 (33.6)
  • *Measured with the Fagerstroem test for nicotine dependency, “low” = 0–2 points, “medium” = 3–4 points, “high” = 5–10 points; †Mantel–Haenszel test for trend; ‡does not sum up to 100% because of rounding error; §“When do you wish to stop smoking?” (“not within the next 6 months” = unmotivated smokers, “within the next 6 months but not within the next 4 weeks” = ambivalent smokers and “within the next 4 weeks” = motivated smokers); ¶measured with the AUDIT-PC questionnaire: “no” = 0 to 4 points, “yes” = 5 to 20 points.

  • AUDIT-PC, Alcohol Use Disorder Identification Test – Primary Care; ETC, Emergency Department-initiated tobacco control.