Table 2

Characteristics of citations

Source of citationCitations in magazines (n = 77)Citations in newspapers (n = 88)
% n % n
Medical/scientific journal62(48)70(62)
Government report23(18)27(24)
Symposium/conference proceeding5(4)1(1)
Book6(5)0(0)
Tobacco industry position paper1(1)0(0)
Dissertation1(1)1(1)
χ2 = 9.75; p = 0.03
  • Differences between magazines and newspapers were analysed using the χ2 statistic.