Table 1

Reliability of questions assessing secondhand smoke exposure (SHSe) among adults

Reference populationAssessmentExposure timeExposure sourceValues
SHSe status (yes/no)
 Coultas et al, 198926: 149 participants aged 21–79 years asked 4–6 months apart asked if the source had smoked daily for ≥6 monthsSHSe statusPregnancyMotherκ=0.73***
ChildhoodMotherκ=0.87***
Fatherκ=0.85***
 Brownson et al, 199325: 37 cases and 73 controls asked 1.7–1.9 years apart. All non-smoking women participants of a larger lung cancer study in Missouri.SHSe statusChildhoodParents93.6%, κ=0.82; SE=0.095
All household members82.7%, κ=0.60; SE=0.090
AdulthoodSpouse83.6%, κ=0.67; SE=0.095
All household members80.0%, κ=0.59; SE=0.093
Living with a smoker (yes/no)
 Pron et al, 198827: 117 controls (63 females and 54 males) in a case-control study of lung cancer in Toronto asked 6 months apartEver living in a house with a regular smokerLifetimeAny
  • κ=0.66; SE=0.08 (females: κ=0.61; SE=0.12) (males: κ=0.70; SE=0.11)

Living with a regular smokerAdulthoodWifeN=53; κ=0.89; SE=0.064
HusbandN=61; κ=0.89; SE=0.059
Childrenκ=0.24; SE=0.106
Motherκ=0.76; SE=0.103
Fatherκ=0.44; SE=0.077
Siblingκ=0.57; SE=0.117
Other (relatives)κ=0.16; SE=0.137
Other (non-relatives)κ=0.02; SE=0.093
Duration of exposure
 Pron et al, 198827: 117 controls (62 females and 53 males) in a case-control study of lung cancer in Toronto asked 6 months apart
  • Years of SHSe

  • Living with a regular smoker

LifetimeAny
  • r=0.45; 95% CI 0.29 to 0.58 (females: r=0.46; 95% CI 0.24 to 0.64) (males: r=0.44; 95% CI 0.19 to 0.63)

SpouseN=58; r=0.25; 95% CI −0.01 to 0.48
WifeN=22; r=0.37; 95% CI −0.06 to 0.68
HusbandN=36; r=0.20; 95% CI −0.14 to 0.50
ParentN=40; r=0.48 95% CI 0.20 to 0.69
MotherN=8; r=0.69; 95% CI −0.03 to 0.94
FatherN=32; r=0.46 95% CI 0.13 to 0.70
Other (relatives)N=17; r=0.59; 95% CI 0.15 to 0.83
 Coultas et al, 198926: 149 participants aged 21–79 years asked 4–6 months apartYears of SHSeChildhoodMotherN=33; r=0.76
FatherN=57; r=0.75
OthersN=26; r=0.63
Years of SHSe sharing the home with smoker(s)AdulthoodSpouseN=40; r=0.95
Other household membersN=67; r=0.78
Hours per day of SHSeChildhoodMotherN=31; r=0.18
FatherN=55; r=0.54
OthersN=20; r=0.51
AdulthoodSpouseN=39; r=0.25
Other household membersN=58; r=0.54
 Brownson et al, 199325:37 cases and 73 controls asked 1.7–1.9 years apart. All non-smoking women participants of a larger lung cancer study in Missouri.Pack-years of SHSeChildhoodAll household members60.9%, r=0.71
Parents73.6%, r=0.81
AdulthoodAll household members52.7%, r=0.77
Spouse60.0%, r=0.80
Intensity of exposure
 Coultas et al, 198926: 149 participants aged 21–79 years asked 4–6 months apart. Amount of cigarettes per day respondents were exposed to by the source for ≥6 months.
  • Categorical cigarettes per day (<1, 1, >1 pack/day, or unknown)

ChildhoodMotherN=48; κ=0.22*
FatherN=79; κ=0.04*
AdulthoodSpouseN=64; κ=−0.04*
 Pron et al, 198827: 117 controls (62 females and 53 males) in a case-control study of lung cancer in Toronto asked 6 months apartNo. of smokers living in the home
  • κ=0.55; SE=0.071 (females: κ=0.52; SE=0.1) (males: κ=0.57; SE=0.1)

 Johansson et al, 200528: 15 smoking parents asked 2 weeks apartNo. of smokers living in the home r=0.5
  • *p<0.05; **p<0.01; ***p<0.001.

  • Percentage agreement.

  • κ, kappa; r, correlation coefficient.