Abstract
We estimate the increment in Massachusetts Medicaid program costs attributable to smoking from December 20, 1991 to 1998. We describe how our methods improve upon earlier estimates of analogous costs at the national level. Current costs to the Massachusetts Medicaid program approximate the payments to Massachusetts under the tobacco settlement of November 1998. Whether these payments are viewed as appropriate compensation for Medicaid costs over time depends upon the rate of increase in future health care costs, the rate of decline in smoking, the proportion of smoking that should be attributed to the actions of the tobacco companies and the likelihood the state would have prevailed at trial. The costs to the Medicaid program are dwarfed by the internal costs to smokers themselves.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Basu, Joy. (1996). “Data View: Border Crossing Adjustment and Personal Health Care Spending by State,” Health Care Financing Review 18(1), 215-236.
Becker, Gary S., and Kevin M. Murphy. (1988). “A Theory of Rational Addiction,” Journal of Political Economy 96, 675-700.
Becker, Gary S., Michael Grossman, and Kevin M. Murphy. (1991). “Rational Addiction and the Effect of Price on Consumption,” American Economic Review 81, 237-241.
Becker, Gary S., Michael Grossman, and Kevin M. Murphy. (1994). “An Empirical Analysis of Cigarette Addiction,” American Economic Review 84, 396-418.
Cederlof, R., Lars Friberg, and T. Lundman. (1977). “The Interactions of Smoking, Environment and Heredity and Their Implications for Disease Etiology. A Report of Epidemiological Studies on the Swedish Twin Registries,” Acta Medica Scandinavica Supplementum 612, 1-128.
Congressional Budget Office. (1998). “The Proposed Tobacco Settlement: Issues from a Federal Perspective,” Washington, DC: CBO.
Court TV. (1998). “States Announce Settlement with Tobacco Companies,” http:/ /www.courttv.com/ trials/ tobacco/ national/ 111698 _ctv.html. November 16.
Cutler, David M., Mark McClellan, and Joseph P. Newhouse. (1999). “The Costs and Benefits of Intensive Treatment for Cardiovascular Disease.” In Jack Triplett ed., Measuring the Prices of Medical Treatments. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.
Cutler, David M., Arnold M. Epstein, Richard G. Frank, Raymond S. Hartman, Charles King, and Joseph P. Newhouse. (1998a). “The Impact of Smoking on Medicaid Spending in Massachusetts: 1970-1997: Methods.” June 15.
Cutler, David M., Arnold M. Epstein, Richard G. Frank, Raymond S. Hartman, Charles King, and Joseph P. Newhouse. (1998b). “The Impact of Smoking on Medicaid Spending in Massachusetts: 1970-1998: Results from the Inclusive Approach for Adults.” July 1.
Cutler, David M., Arnold M. Epstein, Richard G. Frank, Raymond S. Hartman, Charles King, and Joseph P. Newhouse. (1998c). “The Impact of Smoking on Medicaid Spending in Massachusetts: 1991-1998: Results from the Disease-Specific Approach for Adults and Overall Summary.” July 11.
Cutler, David M., Jonathan Gruber, Raymond S. Hartman, Mary Beth Landrum, Joseph P. Newhouse, and Meredith B. Rosenthal, “Some Measures of the Economic Impacts of the Tobacco Settlement,” forthcoming.
Doll, R., R. Gray, B. Hafner, and R. Peto. (1980). “Mortality in Relation to Smoking: 22 Years' Observations on Female British Doctors,” British Medical Journal 280, 967-971.
Doll, R., and R. Peto. (1976). “Mortality in Relation to Smoking: 20 Years' Observations on Male British Doctors,” British Medical Journal 2, 1525-1536.
Doll, R., R. Peto, K. Wheatley, R. Gray, and I. Sutherland. (1994). “Mortality in Relation to Smoking: 40 Years' of Observations on Male British Doctors,” British Medical Journal 309, 901-911.
Duan, Naihua. (1983). “Smearing Estimate: A Nonparametric Retransformation Method,” Journal of the American Statistical Association 78, 605-610.
Duan, Naihua, Willard G. Manning, Carl N. Morris, and Joseph P. Newhouse. (1983). “A Comparison of Alternative Models for the Demand for Medical Care,” Journal of Business and Economic Statistics 1(2), 115-126.
Frank, Richard G., Thomas G. McGuire, Elizabeth H. Notman, and Rebecca M. Woodward. (1996). “Developments in Managed Behavioral Health Care.” In R. Mandersheid and M. Sonnenschein eds., Mental Health U.S., 1996. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
Gravelle, Jane, and Dennis Zimmerman. (1994). Cigarette Taxes to Fund Health Care Reform: An Economic Analysis. Washington, DC: Congressional Research Service.
Hammond, E. Culyer. (1966). “Smoking in Relation to the Death Rates of One Million Men and Women,” National Cancer Institute Monograph 19, 127-204.
Kahn, H. A. (1966). “The Dorn Study of Smoking and Mortality among U.S. Veterans: Report on Eight and One-Half Years of Observation,” National Cancer Institute Monograph 19, 1-125.
Kramer, M. S. (1987). “Intrauterine Growth and Gestational Duration Determinants,” Pediatrics 80, 502-511.
Lamphere, JoAnn, Normandy Brangan, Sharon Bee, and Rafael Semansky. (1998). Reforming the Health Care System: State Profiles 1998. Washington, DC: American Association of Retired Persons.
Manning, Willard G., Emmett B. Keeler, Joseph P. Newhouse, Elizabeth M. Sloss, and Jeffrey Wasserman. (1989). “The Taxes of Sin: Do Smokers and Drinkers Pay Their Way?” Journal of the American Medical Association 261, 1604-1609.
Manning, Willard G., Emmett B. Keeler, Joseph P. Newhouse, Elizabeth M. Sloss and Jeffrey Wasserman. (1991). The Costs of Poor Health Habits. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
McGinnis, J. Michael, and William H. Foege. (1993). “Actual Causes of Death in the United States,” Journal of the American Medical Association 270, 2207-2212.
McIntosh, I. D. (1984). “Smoking and Pregnancy: Attributable Risks and Public Health Implications,” Canadian Journal of Public Health /Revue Canadienne de Sante Publique 75(2), 141-148.
Meyer, M. B., B. S. Jonas, and J. A. Tonascia. (1976). “Perinatal Events Associated with Maternal Smoking During Pregnancy,” American Journal of Epidemiology 103, 464-476.
Miller, Leonard, Xivlan Zhang, Thomas Novotny, Dorothy P. Rice, and Wendy Max. (1998). “State Estimates of Medicaid Expenditures Attributable to Cigarette Smoking, Fiscal Year 1998,” Public Health Reports 113 March-April.
Miller, Vincent P., Caroline R. James, Carla Ernst, and François Collin. (1997). “Smoking-Attributable Medical Care Costs: Models and Results.” Berkeley: Berkeley Economic Research Associates. September 3 (available at www.bera.com).
Miller, Vincent P., Caroline R. James, Carla Ernst, and François Collins. (1999). “Measuring the Medical Costs of Smoking in the USA,” Social Science and Medicine 48, 375-391.
Napier, K. (1996). “Cigarettes: What the Warning Label Doesn't Tell You. The First Comprehensive Guide to the Health Consequences of Smoking.” New York: American Council on Science and Health.
Newhouse, Joseph P. (1992). “Medical Care Costs: How Much Welfare Loss?” Journal of Economic Perspectives 6(3), 3-21.
Newhouse, Joseph P., and the Insurance Experiment Group. (1993) Free for All? Lessons from the RAND Health Insurance Experiment. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Rosenthal, Meredith B., David M. Cutler, Richard G. Frank, Raymond S. Hartman, Mary Beth Landrum, and Joseph P. Newhouse, “Estimating the Costs of Public Health Evils Using Observational Data,” forthcoming.
Rubin, Donald. (1998). State of Minnesota District Court, Second Judicial District, Transcript of Proceedings, pp. 14852-15087. May 1.
Shoven, John B., J. O. Sundberg, and John P. Bunker. (1989). “The Social Security Cost of Smoking.” In D. Wide ed., Economics of Aging. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Stellman, S. D., and L. Garfinkel. (1986). “Smoking Habits and Tar Levels in a New American Society: Prospective Study of 1.2 Million Men and Women,” Journal of the National Cancer Institute 76, 1057-1063.
Tobacco Control Resource Center, Northeastern University. 1998. “The AG Settlement.” http://www.tobacco.neu.edu/Extra/analysis_of_MSA.htm. November 18.
U.S. Department of Health, Education and Welfare. (1979). Smoking and Health: A Report of the Surgeon General. DHEW Publication no. PHS 79-50066. Washington, DC: U.S. Public Health Service.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (1989). 1989 Surgeon General's Report. Washington, DC: U.S. Public Health Service.
Viscusi, W. Kip. (1995). “Cigarette Taxation and the Social Consequences of Smoking,” Tax Policy and the Economy 9, 51-101.
Viscusi, W. Kip. (1999). “The Government Composition of the Insurance Cost of Smoking,” Journal of Law and Economics XLII October, 575-609.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cutler, D.M., Epstein, A.M., Frank, R.G. et al. How Good a Deal Was the Tobacco Settlement?: Assessing Payments to Massachusetts. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 21, 235–261 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1007863408004
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1007863408004