Table 1 Number of participants, response and quitting rates in seven experimental groups
Self helpAll counselledPlanned number of sessions (total duration of sessions)
5 (50 minutes)7 (Booster) (80 minutes)3 (105 minutes)5 (Booster) (135 minutes)5 (210 minutes)7 (Booster) (240 minutes)
Enrolled participants156447581289263819812749826
Followed 6 months7432411653120431434409433
Response rate0.480.520.510.460.530.530.550.52
Respondent quit rate0.160**0.208**0.198*0.308*0.1620.2030.2320.224
95% CI0.134 to 0.1870.192 to 0.2240.167 to 0.2280.226 to 0.3910.128 to 0.1970.165 to 0.2410.191 to 0.2730.185 to 0.263
Enrolled quit rate0.076**0.108**0.100*0.141*0.0850.1080.1270.117
95% CI0.063 to 0.0890.100 to 0.1170.084 to 0.1160.099 to 0.1830.066 to 0.1050.087 to 0.1300.103 to 0.1510.095 to 0.139
Mean number of sessions completed1.561.830.740.921.381.51
  • **0.005 significance level for the difference between these two rates (χ2 test).

  • *0.05 significance level for the difference between these two rates (χ2 test).

  • No other planned comparisons found significant differences between rates.