Table 2

Mean (SD) differences in motivation to quit smoking overall and by experimental condition

Warning labelOverall
n=740
Experimental conditions
Loss-framed branded packs
n=123
Gain-framed branded packs
n=253
Loss-framed
plain packs
n=131
Gain-framed
plain packs
n=233
Lung disease (A)5.1 (2.0)C,D5.1 (2.1)D5.0 (2.0)C,D4.8 (2.0)D5.4 (1.8)C,D
Cancer (B)5.2 (2.0)C,D5.2 (2.1)D5.1 (2.0)C,D4.9 (2.0)C,D5.5 (1.8)C,D
Mortality (C)4.8 (2.1)A,B,D4.9 (2.2)D4.8 (2.0)A,B,D4.5 (2.2)B5.1 (2.0)A,B,D
Stroke/heart attack (D)4.3 (2.1)A,B,C4.4 (2.0)A,B,C4.2 (2.1)A,B,C4.1 (2.2)A,B4.4 (1.9)A,B,C
  • Motivation to quit was captured on a 7-point scale with higher values indicating stronger cessation motivation. Superscript letters adjacent to means within a column indicate significant differences at an overall α of 0.05 in paired t tests between warning labels using a Bonferroni adjustment for multiple comparisons.