Table 3

Impact of topic of text-only e-cigarette warning

     Topic of text-only warning
(1) Nicotine addiction
Mean (SD)
(2) Hazard
Mean (SD)
(3) Hazard + harm
Mean (SD)
1 vs 2
d
2 vs 3
d
Intended effects
Attention to message3.40 (1.13)3.81 (.99)3.78 (1.02)0.39**−0.03
Believability4.17 (.91)3.52 (1.00)3.62 (1.06)−0.68**0.10
Negative affect2.30 (1.12)2.69 (1.06)2.54 (1.15)0.36**−0.14
Anticipated social interactions2.28 (1.33)2.71 (1.34)2.67 (1.33)0.32**−0.03
Cognitive elaboration3.03 (1.31)3.49 (1.21)3.50 (1.29)0.36**0.02
Interest in e-cigarette use (current users only)2.39 (.75)2.31 (.73)2.29 (.79)−0.11−0.03
Perceived message effectiveness3.13 (1.09)3.69 (1.00)3.63 (1.10)0.53**−0.06
Unintended effects
Message reactance2.44 (1.03)2.81 (1.01)2.83 (1.16)0.36**0.02
Anticipated message avoidance2.50 (1.18)2.58 (1.19)2.62 (1.25)0.060.03
Interest in cigarette use (current smokers only)2.30 (.69)2.32 (.73)2.33 (.72)0.020.02
%%%hh
Interest in cigarette use (non-smokers only)5770.080.01
  • d, standardised mean difference; h, standardised proportion difference. Risk belief findings appear in online supplementary table S2 and S3.

  • **p<0.001.