Table 2

Whether participant had an overall negative reaction to the ‘standard’ and dissuasive cigarettes and differences by demography and smoking status

VariableStandard cigarette‘Smoking kills’ cigaretteGreen cigarette‘Toxic’ cigarette
%nχ2 P value%nχ2 P value%nχ2 P value%nχ2 P value
Overall85445944929348096497
Age15.94<0.00112.840.00216.94<0.00110.030.007
 12–13 years9415199161100156100160
 14–15 years79152911729017094175
 16–17 years83142931599115495162
Gender0.33n.s.0.10n.s.5.320.0211.71n.s.
 Female86243942689526897272
 Male84201942239021195224
SES0.28n.s.0.10n.s.0.12n.s.0.004n.s.
 Low and medium84111951269312396126
 High85327943609335196365
Ethnicity3.680.0550.05n.s.0.12n.s.0.10n.s.
 Other/prefer not to say7871958692829685
 White British86369944029339496408
Smoking status63.69<0.00140.60<0.00136.59<0.00124.71<0.001
 Never-smoker90402974309642098432
 Ever-smoker5337775476538557
Susceptibility*26.70<0.00110.140.00114.28 <0.00111.910.001
 Non-susceptible95296983079830299305
 Susceptible78105921229011794126
  • Overall reaction: Total score across nine reaction items, binary coded into negative (<26) or neutral or positive reaction (>27).

  • *Never-smokers only.

  • χ2, Pearson χ2; SES, socioeconomic status.